Grace Period Violation
Summary
The BPA/IPC Single Code of Practice (June 2024), Clause 5.2 and Annex B, mandates a minimum 10-minute grace period for all parking types before a charge can be issued. 'A parking charge must not be issued during a Grace Period.' If your ANPR timestamps show an overstay of 10 minutes or less, this is a complete defense — the operator has no discretion to override the Code. Published POPLA statistics show approximately 75% success where the overstay falls within the mandatory grace window and the timestamps are clearly documented.
Legal Basis
BPA/IPC Single Code of Practice (Version 1, 27 June 2024), Clause 5.2: 'A grace period as set out at Annex B must be allowed. A parking charge must not be issued during a Grace Period.' Annex B minimum grace periods: Free parking (all types) — 10 minutes. Pay-and-display — 10 minutes. Pay-on-departure — 10 minutes. Permit areas — 10 minutes. The Code applies to all BPA and IPC member operators.
When This Defense Applies
This defense applies when the ANPR entry and exit timestamps on the PCN show a total parking duration, or an overstay beyond the paid or permitted period, of 10 minutes or less. The grace period applies at both ends: on arrival (time to read signs and decide whether to stay) and on departure (time to pack up and leave after permitted period ends). Check the PCN timestamps carefully — the overstay calculation must use the correct start of the permitted period.
Evidence Required
The following is needed to run this defense:
- ANPR entry and exit times — these should be printed on the PCN itself
- Evidence of permitted parking time (paid period, displayed ticket, or stated free period)
- Calculation showing overstay is 10 minutes or less
- Screenshot or photo of the relevant section of the BPA/IPC Code of Practice if appealing to a non-specialist audience
Win Rate
Approximately 75% success at POPLA/IAS where the overstay is demonstrated to fall within the mandatory grace period and the timestamps are undisputed. The Code obligation is absolute — operators cannot argue commercial reasons for not applying it.
Operator-Specific Patterns
Smart Parking: ANPR-heavy enforcement. Known for ignoring the Code grace period at supermarket sites — check timestamps carefully and calculate to the minute. ParkingEye: High volume ANPR at supermarket and retail sites. Grace period violations are common where paid period ends precisely on the hour and the ANPR captures a few minutes of pack-up time.
Sources
- BPA/IPC Single Code of Practice 2024, Clause 5.2 and Annex B
Frequently Asked Questions
- Does the 10-minute grace period apply to free parking time limits too?
- Yes. Annex B of the Single Code of Practice applies the 10-minute grace period to free parking, pay-and-display, pay-on-departure, and permit areas without distinction. If you overstayed a 2-hour free limit by 8 minutes, the grace period defense applies.
- The operator says they gave me a 5-minute grace period — is that enough?
- No. The Code sets a mandatory minimum of 10 minutes. An operator cannot contract out of the Code requirements. If they applied less than 10 minutes, the PCN was issued prematurely and must be cancelled.
- What if I can't verify the ANPR timestamps are accurate?
- The operator bears the burden of proving the contravention. If you have independent evidence (dashcam, receipts with timestamps, phone GPS history) showing your actual departure time, present it. Where ANPR accuracy is also in dispute, consider raising both the grace period ground and the ANPR error ground together.
- Does this apply to council-issued PCNs?
- The BPA/IPC grace period Code applies to private parking operators only. Council PCNs are governed by the Traffic Management Act 2004 and associated regulations — different rules apply. The payment-error and ANPR-error defenses may be more relevant for council tickets.
Related
Got a ticket? Find out if you can win.
GetRighted checks your situation against all known defenses — free in under 2 minutes.
Check My Ticket